Water Mill, NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Browse a variety of Water Mill properties and homes for sale, and learn more about the local real estate market.

Water Mill, NY Real Estate Market Trends

In 2022, Water Mill home prices were down nearly 48% compared to the previous period. The median selling price was approximately $2,100,000. Water Mill homes generally sell within 161 days. 

Median Sale Price


# of Homes Sold


Median Days on the Market


How Competitive is the Water Mill, NY Market?

Not that competitive. The average Water Mill home sells for around 5% less than the listing price.

Ready to find your next home in Water Mill, NY?

Let's Work Together